In this post, I am going to talk about a film “La mala educacion” written and directed by Pedro Almodóvar. The film is focused mainly on the problem of paedophilia in Catholic church. “Topically, the film coincides with public outcry over a growing number of molestation cases reported against Catholic clergy(…)” (Saenz, 2013, p.251)
Although Almodovar’s films are widely known as controversial, this one is special, because director decided to present the paedophile priest as a type of person, whom we can even symphatise with. Although he is not like that from the beginning.

In a particular scene in “La mala educacion” we can see Ignacio singing to the priest by the lake. We can see a true, almost unhealthy fascination in Father Manolo’s eyes. Camera is moving behind the bush, and then we can hear little Ignacio screaming “NO”. That’s where the abuse of Catholic church is shown. Camera comes back, and we can see Ignacio when he is trying to run away. He fells, and we can see a blood dripping down in the middle of his forehead and the image splits in a half. “(…) the moment also evokes the experience of disassociation which is known to be a common symptom of the childhood sexual abuse” (Saenz, 2013, p.252).
“Ignaccio felt “split in two” (male and female, victim and killer) after he was molested by Father Manolo” (Kinder, 2009. p. 289).
When we meet Father Manolo and his pupil Ignacio, they’re living in Spain in 60’, being homosexual in Franco’s Spain was highly illegal. There was a scene, where Ignaccio was singing for Father Manolo on his Birthday. The Priest started to cry, he was visibly touched by Ignaccio’s voice. From what we can see in the film, we can suspect, that Priest may be even in love with Ignaccio. Even Almodovar admitted that in one of his interviews “(…) this Priest is madly in love with this kid. That the Priest recognises that love as illegitimate and as a crime. As something prohibited” (Almodovar for “All things considered”, 2004).
Later on in the film, Father Manolo becomes Senor Berenguer. He leaves the past behind him without any consequences „there is something particularly sinister about the ease with which the paedophile priest father Manolo has reinvented himself in the role of the modern family man and successful editor, a position that gives him the opportunity to discover and promote young writers.” (Ibanez, 2013, p.169). He appears in a life of Ignaccio once again and falls in love with his brother Juan. He is charmed by his masculinity. When Juan is working out it is hard for Berenguer to stop looking at him. He is vulnerable. We can see him crying in the rain when Juan leaves him. He is easily manipulated and blackmailed by Ignaccio. He is definitely not the same person as he was before, when he was wearing a soutane and had much more power, because he was part of a very big institution- Catholic church. It means, that he was a bad person when he was a part of a church, and the church itself was the source of evil. Almodovar presents the priest as a symphatetic person, because he was a victim as well, a part of the system and a broken hearted man.
Bibliography:
Ibanez, J. (2013). Memory, Politics and the Post-Transition in Almodóvar’s Cinema. In Vernon, K. M., & D’Lugo, M. (Eds.) A companion to Pedro Almodovar (pp.153-175). John Wiley & Sons
Saenz N. (2013) Domesticating Violence in the Films of Pedro Almodóvar. In Vernon, K. M., & D’Lugo, M. (Eds.) A companion to Pedro Almodovar (pp.244-261). John Wiley & Sons.
Kinder M. (2009). All about the Brothers. Retroseriality in Almodóvar’s Cinema. In Epps B. & Kakoudaki D. (Eds.) All about Almodóvar: A Passion for Cinema (pp. 267-294). University of Minnesota Press.
An interview with Pedro Almodóvar for “All things Concidered” retrieved from:
